Who’s Afraid of Peer Review?

ILLUSTRATION: DAVID PLUNKERT

 

Tangled web.

The location of a journal’s publisher, editor, and bank account are often continents apart. Explore an interactive version of this map.

CREDIT: DAVID QUINN AND DANIEL WIESMANN

 

Peer review reviewed.

Few journals did substantial review that identified the paper’s flaws.

CREDIT: C. SMITH/SCIENCE

Who’s Afraid of Peer Review?

Between January and June 2013, Science contributing correspondent John Bohannon submitted 304 fake research papers to open access journals. The papers were designed with such grave scientific flaws that they should have been rejected immediately by editors and peer reviewers.

Click for interactive figure.

This map shows which journals accepted or rejected the papers, along with the email correspondences that led to those outcomes. Using data from email IP addresses and bank invoices, it also compares the countries where publishers claim to be with the location of their editors and bank accounts—information that is frequently obscured by open access publishers.

Read the full report here: http://www.sciencemag.org/content/342/6154/60.full

Citation: J. Bohannon, “Who’s Afraid of Peer Review?” Science 342, 60-65 (2013)

The fake papers used for this project were created with help from Nicholas Douris (1), Shangyu Hong (1), ffolliott Martin Fisher (1), Olga Dudchenko (2),(3),(4), Elena Stamenova (2),(3),(4), Jim Robinson (2),(3),(4), Miriam Huntley (2),(3),(4), Benjamin MacDonald Schmidt (2),(3),(4),(5),(6), Adrian Sanborn (2),(3),(4), Ivan Bochkov (2),(3),(4), and Erez Lieberman Aiden (2),(3),(4)

.
  • (1) Harvard Medical School, Boston, Massachusetts
  • (2) School of Engineering and Applied Sciences, Harvard University, Cambridge, Massachusetts
  • (3) Baylor College of Medicine, Houston, Texas
  • (4) Rice University, Houston, Texas
  • (5) Broad Institute of MIT and Harvard, Cambridge, Massachusetts
  • (6) College of Social Science and Humanities, Northeastern University, Boston, Massachusetts

Data

These data sets were curated by John Bohannon and Kelly Servick.

Summary data spreadsheet [data_summary.zip] (57 KB) documentation[data_summary_readme.txt]

Papers [papers.zip] (15 MB) documentation [papers_readme.txt]

Emails [emails.zip] (268 MB) documentation [emails_readme.txt]

Publisher Journal Outcome Records
Academe Research Journals International Journal of Biomedical Science Research dead emails
Academic Research Centre of Canada Experimental Agriculture & Horticulture review emails
Academic Research Publishing Agency Journal of Pharmacy and Clinical Sciences accepted emails
Academy Journals Current Cellular Biochemistry rejected emails
Academy Publish Journal of Medical Research and Sciences dead emails
Acta Biochimica Polonica The Journal of the Polish Biochemical Society rejected emails
Adis, Springer Healthcare Drugs in R&D rejected emails
Advanced Research Journals International Journal of Pharmacy and Pharmacology dead emails
Advanced Research Journals International Journal of Advances in Pharmaceutical Sciences accepted emails
Advancements and Development in Technology International Aditi Journal of Microbiology and Biotechnology dead emails
Ain Shams University Egyptian Academic Journal of Biological Sciences dead emails
Akademik Plus Publication European Journal of Biological and Chemical Research dead emails
American Association of Neurological Surgeons Neurosurgical Focus rejected emails
American Journal of PharmTech Research American Journal of PharmTech Research accepted emails
American Society for Microbiology mBio rejected emails
American V-King Scientific Publishing Journal of Life Medicine rejected emails
ANSINetwork Journal of Medical Sciences rejected emails
AOSIS OpenJournals African Journal of Primary Health Care & Family Medicine rejected emails
Apex Journals Journal of Science And Enviromental Impact review emails
ARPN Journals Journal of Agricultural and Biological Science accepted emails
Ashdin Publishing International Journal of Medical Biology rejected emails
Asian Economic and Social Society Journal of Asian Scientific Research accepted emails
Association of Basic Medical Sciences of Federation of Bosnia and Herzegovina Bosnian Journal of Basic Medical Sciences rejected emails
Association of Overseas Chinese Agricultural, Biological and Food Engineers(AOCABFE), Chinese Society of Agricultural Engineering(CSAE) International Journal of Agricultural and Biological Engineering review emails
Association of Pharm innovators Asian Journal of Biomedical and Pharmaceutical Sciences accepted emails
Association of Physiologist, Pharmacists and Pharmacologists (APPP) National Journal of Physiology, Pharmacy and Pharmacology accepted emails
AstonJournals Chemical Sciences Journal rejected emails
Ayub Medical College Abbottabad Pakistan Journal of Ayub Medical College Abbottabad review emails
Baishideng Publishing Group World Journal of Radiology rejected emails
Basic Research Journals Journal of Medicine and Clinical Sciences accepted emails
Bentham open The Open Bioactive Compounds Journal accepted emails
Bio Tech Systems Journal of Biotech Research accepted emails
Bioflux Advances in Agriculture & Botanics accepted emails
BioInfo International Journal of Drug Discovery accepted emails
BioIT international Journals International Journal of Pharmaceutical Applications accepted emails
BioMed Central Neuroglia rejected emails
Biomedical Communications Group African Journal of Biomedical Research accepted emails
Biomedical Informatics Publishing Group Bioinformation accepted emails
BioMedSciDirect Publications International Journal of Biological & Medical Research accepted emails
Boreal Environment Research Publishing Board Boreal Environment Research rejected emails
British Association of Academic Research British Journal of Medical and Health Sciences accepted emails
Canadian Center of Science and Education Cancer and Clinical Oncology rejected emails
Center for Enhancing Knowledge European International Journal of Science and Technology accepted emails
Centraalbureau voor Schimmelcultures Studies in Mycology rejected emails
Centre For Info Bio Technology International Journal of Basic and Applied Medical Sciences accepted emails
Chinese Medical Association Chinese Medical Journal rejected emails
Cloud Journals International Journal of Advanced Pharmaceutical Science and Technology submission fee emails
Company of Biologists BiO rejected emails
Contemporary Journal Concept Press Mathematical and Computational Forestry & Natural-Resource Sciences rejected emails
Cosmic Journals International journal of Education and Applied Research accepted emails
CSCanada Advances in Natural Science accepted emails
David Publishing Journal of Life Sciences accepted emails
Deccan Pharma Journals Deccan Journal of Medicinal Chemistry accepted emails
Discovery Publishing Group Medical Science Journal accepted emails
Dove Medical Press Ltd Drug Design, Development and Therapy accepted emails
E Business Navigators Biology and Medicine accepted emails
e-Century Publishing Corporation American Journal of Nuclear Medicine and Molecular Imaging rejected emails
E-International Scientific Research Journal Consortium Americas Journal of Medicine dead emails
e-journals International Research Journal of Medical Sciences accepted emails
e-MED Ltd Grand Rounds rejected emails
e3Journals Journal of Biotechnology and Pharmaceutical Research accepted emails
Ecological Society of Korea Journal of Ecology and Environment dead emails
Edizioni Danaus, Palermo Biodiversity Journal rejected emails
eJournals of Academic Research & Reviews eJournal of Biological Sciences accepted emails
Electronic Center for International Scientific Information International Journal of Agriculture: Research and Review accepted emails
Electronic Center for International Scientific Information International Journal of Agriculture: Research and Review accepted emails
Elmer Press World Journal of Oncology rejected emails
Elsevier Drug Invention Today accepted emails
Engg Journals Publication International Journal of Engineering Science and Technology rejected emails
Engineering and Technology Publishing Journal of Medical and Bioengineering accepted emails
Engineering, Technology & Applied Science Research Engineering, Technology & Applied Science Research rejected emails
Erudite Journals Limited Erudite Journal of Medicine and Medical Science Research accepted emails
Euresian Publications Universal Journal of Environmental Research and Technology accepted emails
European Journal of Chemistry European Journal of Chemistry accepted emails
Food Science Publisher The Journal of Functional Foods in Health and Disease rejected emails
Friends Science Publishers International Journal of Agriculture and Biology rejected emails
Frontiers Media Frontiers in Pharmacology of Anti-Cancer Drugs rejected emails
Genetics Society of America Genes | Genomes | Genetics rejected emails
GKS Publishers Research in Biotechnology accepted emails
Global Academic Society Indian journal of Scientific Research accepted emails
Global Advanced Research Journals Global Advanced Research Journal of Medicine and Medical Sciences accepted emails
Global Journals, Inc. (US) Global Journal of Medical Research accepted emails
Global Research Journals Journal of Pharmacy and Pharmacological Research accepted emails
Global Research Online International Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences Review and Research accepted emails
Global Researchers Journals Journal of Physiology and Pharmacology Advances accepted emails
Green Earth Research Foundation GERF Bulletin of Bioscience accepted emails
Green Global Foundation Journal of Soil and Nature dead emails
Greener Journals Greener Journal of Medical Sciences accepted emails
Growing Science Publishing Company Current Chemistry Letters rejected emails
Gunther Eysenbach Journal of Medical Internet Research submission fee emails
GVGS Research Journal of Pharmaceutical, Biological and Chemical Sciences accepted emails
Herald International Research Journals Herald Journal of Medicine and Medical Science accepted emails
Herbert Open Access Journals Pharmaceutical Technology & Drug Research rejected emails
Hikari Ltd. Clinical and Experimental Medical Sciences accepted emails
Hindawi Publishing Corporation Chemotherapy Research and Practice rejected emails
Horizon Scientific Press Current Issues in Molecular Biology rejected emails
Hygeia Hygeia accepted emails
IBC Interdisciplinary Bio Central rejected emails
Ibima Publishing Advances in Cancer: Research & Treatment rejected emails
iConcept Press Emerging Issues in Medical Diagnosis and Treatment rejected emails
IJSAT Publishers International Journal of Science and Advanced Technology accepted emails
Independent Publishing house Professional Medical Journal accepted emails
Indian Agricultural Research Journals Open Access Journal of Medicinal and Aromatic Plants submission fee emails
Indian Society for Education and Environment Indian Journal of Drugs and Diseases accepted emails
Indo American Journal of Pharmaceutical Research Indo American Journal of Pharmaceutical Research rejected emails
Indo Global Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences Indo Global Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences accepted emails
Industry Research Collaboration Center International Journal on Bioinformatics & Biosciences accepted emails
Innovare Academic Sciences International Journal of Applied Pharmaceutics accepted emails
Innovative Scientific Information & Services Network Bioscience Research accepted emails
Insciences Organisation Stem Cells rejected emails
Insight Knowledge Insight Pharmaceutical Sciences rejected emails
INSInet Publications Global journal of medicinal plant research duplicate emails
INSInet Publications Australian Journal of Basic and Applied Sciences accepted emails
Institute of Electronic & Information Technology Asia-Pacific Science and Culture Journal dead emails
Institute of Physiology, Czech Academy of Sciences Physiological Research rejected emails
InTech Open Access Publisher International Journal of Integrative Medicine accepted emails
International Academic Journals International Journal of AgriScience rejected emails
International Association of Journals & Conferences International Transaction Journal of Engineering, Management, & Applied Sciences & Technologies accepted emails
International Digital Organization for Scientific Information Global Journal of Pharmacology accepted emails
International House for Academic Scientific Research International Journal of Advanced Medical Sciences and Applied Research accepted emails
International Institute for Science, Technology and Education Advances in Life Science and Technology accepted emails
International Journal of Advanced Technology and Engineering Research International Journal of Advanced Technology and Engineering Research accepted emails
International Journal of Chemical and Pharmaceutical Sciences International Journal of Chemical and Pharmaceutical Sciences accepted emails
International Journal of Current Research International Journal of Current Research accepted emails
International Journal of Life Sciences Biotechnology and Pharma Research International Journal of Life Sciences Biotechnology and Pharma Research accepted emails
International Journal of Pharma and Bio Sciences International Journal of Pharma and Bio Sciences accepted emails
International Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences and Drug Research International Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences and Drug Research rejected emails
International Journal of Research in Chemistry and Environment International Journal of Research in Chemistry and Environment rejected emails
International Journal of Research in Pharmacy and Chemistry International Journal of Research in Pharmacy and Chemistry accepted emails
International Journal of Research in Pharmacy and Science International Journal of Research in Pharmacy and Science accepted emails
International Journals of Engineering & Sciences International Journal of Basic & Applied Sciences accepted emails
International Journals of Multidisciplinary Research Academy International Journal of Engineering, Science and Mathematics accepted emails
International Journals of Scientific Research Advances in Biological Sciences accepted emails
International Network for Applied Sciences and Technology Journal of Plant Biology Research accepted emails
International Network for Natural Sciences International Journal of Biomolecules and Biomedicine rejected emails
International Research Journal International Research and Review accepted emails
International Research Journals Agricultural Science Research Journal accepted emails
International Research Journals Journal of Medicine and Medical Sciences accepted emails
International Scholars Journals International Journal of Oncology and Cancer Research accepted emails
International Scientific Publications Ecology & Safety accepted emails
Internet Scientific Publications, LLC The Internet Journal of Herbal and Plant Medicine accepted emails
Interscience Journals Journal of Current Research in Ayurvedic and Pharmaceutical Sciences dead emails
Interscience Open Access Journals International Journal of Pharmacology and Pharmaceutical Technology accepted emails
Iranian Association of Endodontics & Iranian Center for Endodontics Research Iranian Endodontic Journal rejected emails
IRPN International Journal of Science and Technology accepted emails
Israel Medical Association Israel Medical Association Journal rejected emails
Ivy Union Publishing American Journal of Cancer Therapy and Pharmacology rejected emails
Ivyspring International Publisher International Journal of Biological Sciences rejected emails
Japan Poultry Science Association Annals of Cancer Research and Therapy rejected emails
JK Welfare & Pharmascope Foundation International Journal of Research in Pharmaceutical Sciences accepted emails
Journal of Advances in Drug Research Journal of Advances in Drug Research dead emails
Journal of Chemical and Pharmaceutical Research Journal of Chemical and Pharmaceutical Research accepted emails
Journal of Chemical, Biological and Physical Sciences Journal of Chemical, Biological and Physical Sciences accepted emails
Journal of Medical Research Journal of Medical Research dead emails
Kairali Society of Oral & Maxillofacial Pathologists Oral & Maxillofacial Pathology Journal rejected emails
Kamla-Raj Enterprises Journal of Life Sciences submission fee emails
Karger Publishers Case Reports in Oncology rejected emails
KEJA Publications International Journal of Pharmaceutical and Biological Research accepted emails
Kerala Agricultural University, Thrissur, Kerala Journal of Tropical Agriculture rejected emails
Kobe University School of Medicine, Kobe Kobe Journal of Medical Sciences accepted emails
Korean Association for the Study of The Liver Clinical and Molecular Hepatology rejected emails
Korean Society of Phycology Algae rejected emails
Krakow Polish Physiological Society Journal of Physiology and Pharmacology submission fee emails
Liaquat University of Medical and Health Sciences Journal of Liaquat University of Medical and Health Sciences review emails
Libertas Academica Cancer Growth and Metastasis rejected emails
Lifescience Global Journal of Cancer Research Updates accepted emails
LifeSciFeed Ventures Life Sciences Feed dead emails
LIPhealth theHealth submission fee emails
Lippincott Williams & Wilkins Anti-Cancer Drugs rejected emails
Macrothink Institute Journal of Biology and Life Science accepted emails
Malaysian Medical Association Medical Journal of Malaysia submission fee emails
MASAUM Network MASAUM Journal of Medicine and Medical Sciences dead emails
Master Publishing Group International Journal of Biomedical Science accepted emails
Maxwell Scientific Organization Asian Journal of Medical Sciences accepted emails
MDPI AG Cancers rejected emails
MediPOEIA Publication Journal of Current Pharmaceutical Research dead emails
Medipoeia Publication Journal of Applied Pharmaceutical Science accepted emails
Medknow Publications Journal of Natural Pharmaceuticals accepted emails
MedSci Publications National Journal of Community Medicine rejected emails
Medwell Online Research Journal of Pharmacology accepted emails
Mehta Press Current Chemical Research dead emails
Modern Science Publishers Journal of Experimental and Applied Animal Sciences rejected emails
Modern Scientific Press International Journal of Modern Biology and Medicine accepted emails
Narain Publishers Pvt. Ltd World Journal of Surgical Medical and Radiation Oncology accepted emails
National Association for Medical Research National Journal of Medical Research rejected emails
Nature Publishing Group Laboratory Investigation rejected emails
Neoplasia Neoplasia rejected emails
Nikolai Petrovsky Publishing Immunome Research rejected emails
North Carolina State University BioResources rejected emails
OMICS Publishing Group Medicinal Chemistry accepted emails
OmniScientia Journal of Nephrology and Renal Transplantation accepted emails
Online Research Journals Online Journal of Medicine and Medical Science Research accepted emails
Open Access Science Research Publisher International Journal of Medicinal and Aromatic Plants accepted emails
Open Medicine Open Medicine rejected emails
Open Science Co. LLC ePlasty submission fee emails
Oxford University Press Carcinogenesis rejected emails
PAGEPress Publications Drugs and Therapy Studies rejected emails
Pakistan Agricultural Scientists Forum Journal of Animal and Plant Sciences rejected emails
Pakistan Botanical Society Pakistan Journal of Botany rejected emails
PBS Journals Asian Journal of Medical and Clinical Sciences accepted emails
Pelagia Research Library Der Pharmacia Sinica accepted emails
Pensoft Publishers PhytoKeys rejected emails
People’s group People’s Journal of Scientific Research review emails
Pharma Science Monitor Pharma Science Monitor accepted emails
Pharmaceutical and Biological Society Asian Journal of Pharmaceutical and Health Sciences accepted emails
Pharmaceutical Research Foundation Journal of Advanced Pharmaceutical Research accepted emails
Pharmacie Globale International Journal of Comprehensive Pharmacy accepted emails
Pharmacognosy Network Worldwide Pharmacognosy Journal review emails
PharmaInfo Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences and Research accepted emails
PharmaInterScience Publishers International Journal of Pharmacy and Biomedical Sciences accepted emails
PharmSciDirect Publications International Journal of Pharmaceutical and Biomedical Research review emails
PharmTech Publications Journal of Pharmaceutical Science and Technology accepted emails
Photon Foundation International Journal of Medicinal Plants accepted emails
Polish Academy of Sciences Publishing Acta Biologica Cracoviensia review emails
Polish agricultural schools of higher education Electronic Journal of Polish Agricultural Universities review emails
Polish Botanical Society Acta Societatis Botanicorum Poloniae rejected emails
Polish Histochemical and Cytochemical Society Folia Histochemica et Cytobiologica rejected emails
Pontificia Universidad Catalica de Valparaiso Electronic Journal of Biotechnology rejected emails
Portland Press Ltd Biochemical Journal rejected emails
Postgraduate Medical Institute, Peshawar Journal of Postgraduate Medical Institute rejected emails
Power Control Optimization Global Journal of Technology and Optimization accepted emails
Prague Development Center Medical and Health Science Journal dead emails
Praise Worthy Prize International Review of Biophysical Chemistry accepted emails
Prime Journals Prime Research on Medicine dead emails
Professional Medical Publications Pakistan Journal of Medical Sciences rejected emails
Proquest Sustainability: Science, Practice, & Policy rejected emails
Public Library of Science (PLoS) PLoS ONE rejected emails
Radiance Research Academy International Journal of Current Research and Review
Research and Review accepted emails
Research Publisher Journal of Biochemical and Pharmacological Research accepted emails
Royal Society of Medicine Press JRSM Short Reports rejected emails
Rural Research Institute of Physiology & Applied Nutrition Journal of Community Nutrition & Health review emails
Sadguru Publications Journal of Current Chemical & Pharmaceutical Sciences accepted emails
Sage Journal of International Medical Research accepted emails
SAVAP International Academic Research International accepted emails
Scholar Science Journals International Journal of Biomedical Research accepted emails
ScholarJournals Current Botany rejected emails
Scholarly Journals International Scholarly Journal of Medicine accepted emails
Scholarly Research Center American Academic & Scholarly Research Journal dead emails
Sciedu Press Journal of Solid Tumors rejected emails
Science & Knowledge Publishing Corporation Limited European Journal of Biological and Life Sciences accepted emails
Science and Engineering Publishing Company Advances in Chemical Science accepted emails
Science Instinct Publications International Journal of Pharmacology & Toxicology Science accepted emails
Science Journal Publication Science Journal of Medicine and Clinical Trials accepted emails
Science Park Journals Journal of Medicine and Radiology accepted emails
Science Record Journals International Journal of Medical Discovery dead emails
Science Target International Journal of Herbs and Medicinal Plants accepted emails
ScienceDomain International British Journal of Pharmaceutical Research rejected emails
ScienceHuB American Journal of Medical and Dental Sciences accepted emails
Scienpress Ltd International Journal of Health Research and Innovation accepted emails
Sciensage Publications Journal of Advanced Scientific Research accepted emails
Scientific & Academic Publishing International Journal of Cancer and Tumor accepted emails
Scientific Journals International Journal of Medical & Biological Sciences review emails
Scientific Journals Journal of Pharmaceuticals accepted emails
Scientific Research Platform European Journal of Scientific Research accepted emails
Scientific Research Publishing Open Journal of Radiology accepted emails
SciTechnol Journal of Pharmacological & Biomedical Analysis dead emails
Segment Journals Biological Segment accepted emails
SERSC International Journal of Bio-Science and Bio-Technology accepted emails
Shiraz University of Medical sciences Iranian Journal of Immunology rejected emails
Signpost e Journals Signpost Open Access Journal of Biomedical and Pharmaceutical Sciences accepted emails
Silicon Valley Publishers International Journal of Applied Science and Technology accepted emails
Silicon Valley Publishers International Journal of Advances in Science and Technology duplicate emails
Simplex Academic Publishers ScienceJet rejected emails
Singapore Medical Association Singapore Medical Journal submission fee emails
SJournals Scientific Journal of Medical Science accepted emails
Society for Science and Nature International Journal of Advanced Biological Research accepted emails
Society for Scientific Research Journal of Ecobiotechnology dead emails
Society of Applied Sciences Asian Journal of Experimental Biological Sciences accepted emails
Society of Education Advances in Bioresearch accepted emails
Society of Engineering Science and Technology International Journal Of Advances in Engineering Science and Technology review emails
Society Of United Life Sciences, India Scholars Research Journal review emails
Sooraj Publications International Journal of Chemical Sciences and Research accepted emails
Southern Cross Publishing Group Plant Knowledge Journal rejected emails
Sphinx Knowledge House International Journal of PharmTech Research accepted emails
SpringerOpen Biointerphases rejected emails
Swiss Journals Swiss Journal of Medical Science review emails
TCH International Biological and Biomedical Reports dead emails
Technical Journals Online International Journal of Pharmaceutical Studies and Research dead emails
Termedia Publishing House Archives of Medical Science rejected emails
Textroad Journals Journal of Pharmaceutical and Biomedical Sciences accepted emails
Thammasat University Thammasat International Journal of Science and Technology review emails
The Clute Institute American Journal of Health Sciences submission fee emails
The Faculty of Medicine, University of Nis Acta Facultatis Medicae Naisensis accepted emails
The Korean Chemical Society Bulletin of the Korean Chemical Society rejected emails
The National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences (NIEHS) Environmental Health Perspectives rejected emails
The Ribeirao Preto foundation for Scientific Research (FUNPEC) Genetics and Molecular Research accepted emails
The Sims Institute Press Ltd Journal of Experimental & Clinical Assisted Reproduction accepted emails
Therapeutic Solutions, LLC The Journal of Applied Research review emails
Trade Science, Inc Medicinal Chemistry dead emails
Trans Stellar International Journal of Medicine and Pharmaceutical Sciences accepted emails
Transnational Research Journals Universal Journal of Medicine & Dentistry dead emails
Trendz Publications Journal of Innovative trends in Pharmaceutical Sciences accepted emails
Triveni Enterprises Journal of Environmental Biology submission fee emails
Universal Research Publications Current Research in Medicine and Medical Sciences review emails
Universidad Nacional de Cuyo Biocell (Mendoza) review emails
University of Brawijaya, Indonesia Journal of Agricultural Science dead emails
University of California, Irvine Western Journal of Emergency Medicine rejected emails
University of Otago Journal of Health Informatics in Developing Countries rejected emails
University of Puerto Rico Caribbean Journal of Science rejected emails
University of Uludag Journal of Sports Science and Medicine rejected emails
University of Veterinary and Pharmaceutical Sciences, Brno Acta Veterinaria Brno rejected emails
University of Washington Radiology Case Reports rejected emails
University Ss Kiril and Metodij Macedonian Journal of Medical Sciences accepted emails
Versita Open Natural Products against Cancer rejected emails
Veterinary Solutions International Journal of Applied Research in Veterinary Medicine dead emails
Victorquest Publications International Journal of Traditional and Herbal Medicine accepted emails
Wiley Phytotherapy Research rejected emails
Wilolud Journals Continental Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences accepted emails
Wireilla Scientific Publications International Journal of Advances in Biology review emails
World Academic Publishing International Journal of Life Science and Medical Research accepted emails
World Academy of Research and Publication International Journal of Chemical and Environmental Engineering accepted emails
World Academy of Science, Engineering and Technology International Journal of Medical, Pharmaceutical, Biological, and Life Sciences accepted emails
World Science Publisher Journal of Science accepted emails
World Scientific and Engineering Academy and Society WSEAS Transactions on Biology and Biomedicine accepted emails
Wudpecker Research Journals Wudpecker Journal of Medicinal Plants accepted emails
Xinnovem Publishing Group Biomirror accepted emails
Yonsei University College of Medicine Yonsei Medical Journal rejected emails